Lanaya Cardwell was sentenced to 14 years in prison with credit for time served for attempted second-degree cruelty to a juvenile.
www.wafb.com
Lanaya Cardwell sentenced to 14 years in death of daughter Nevaeh Allen
Lanaya Cardwell was sentenced to 14 years in prison with credit for time served for attempted second-degree cruelty to a juvenile. The victim was her own daughter, Nevaeh Allen.
Cardwell’s former boyfriend, Phillip Keegan Gardner, is already serving a life sentence for the second-degree murder of two-year-old Nevaeh in 2021.
Nevaeh’s grandmother, stepsister and biological father all took the stand, each asking Judge Crifasi for the maximum sentence of 20 years.
Gardner’s mother, Kim Holmes, told the judge she tried to get Nevaeh and the other children in that home to safety. She said Cardwell and Gardner failed those kids.
“A child that deserved to be here right now, that can’t be here because of two parents that were selfish, that took away her right, took away my right, took away my grandchildren’s right to live as children and have a normal life,” Holmes said.
Holmes said she believes 14 years is not enough. She addressed Nevaeh’s biological father, Marcus Allen, directly.
“I’m sorry. I’m sorry to Baton Rouge that everybody had to be subject to this pain, to the father, the father. Marcus Allen was a good dad. He wasn’t given the opportunity to be a father to his daughter, but he did his best. I want the record to show that Marcus Allen was a good father, a good father,” Holmes said.
Judge Crifasi called her statement extraordinary.
Marcus Allen told the judge 20 years was not enough, because he will never get 20 years with his daughter.
“This tragedy here will last for generations in this family is one that just didn’t go away. And I know it comes back every holiday, graduation, high school, birth. It just never goes away and it just perpetuates itself,” District Attorney Hillar Moore said.
Marcus Allen looked directly at Cardwell and said he forgives her. He said he found new purpose, found love and became a better man because of this experience.
The sentencing took hours, in part because the state played a recent jail phone call from Cardwell.
“She thought nobody was looking at her and she said she’s ready to hit the streets and get down the hill here and wanted a bottle of wine waiting for her. I think it was a reward and she was bored of being in jail. Well, there’s another person who can’t be bored because they’re not alive and families that are not born because they’re suffering,” Moore said.
Moore said this chapter will never fully close for the family, but his office is satisfied with the sentence and believes they did everything possible to get justice for Nevaeh.