CA FANG JIN: Missing from San Bernardino County, CA - July 2023 - Age 47 *Found Deceased*

1697829633226.png 1697829644136.png

Chinese woman remains missing, while her boyfriend was found dead in San Diego County​

The investigation continues into a missing Chinese national and her friend, a former Navy SEAL from Morongo Valley.

The most recent update in the case came in September, roughly two months after Fan Jin and John Root Fitzpatrick went missing.

San Bernardino County Sheriff’s officials reported that the body of veteran Fitzpatrick, 52, was found last month in the Anza-Borrego Desert State Park.

Sheriff’s spokesperson Mara Rodriguez told the Daily Press on Wednesday that there is no update on Jin's whereabouts, and the missing person's case remains open.

The 47-year-old woman was last heard from in July.

After meeting a man, later identified as Fitzpatrick, online and corresponding with him for six months, Jin decided to meet him, her family said.

“Jin did her best to check into the man’s background, ordering a background report and verifying the man’s identity, military service, and employment record,” according to a GoFundMe account set up by family friend Kyle Zhou.

Jin flew from China to Los Angeles on July 14.

After arriving, she boarded a train from Los Angeles to the Palm Springs area. The following day, she was picked up by a man whom she hired for a tour of the Morongo Basin area, sheriff's officials stated.

Jin had planned to camp in an unknown area in the Morongo Basin, which is situated southeast of Lucerne and Johnson valleys in the High Desert, police stated.

On July 16, the couple was seen on surveillance video purchasing toiletries inside the Marine Corps Exchange at the Marine Corps Air Ground Combat Center in Twentynine Palms, according to a search warrant issued by San Bernardino County Superior Court.

The man took her to Joshua Tree National Park and then “supposedly went camping” with her at “a small town in the desert,” her family said.

The pair reportedly took at least one hiking trip to the desert. Jin also stayed with Fitzpatrick at the Roadrunner Mobile Home Park in Morongo Valley.

Jin continued to send photos to her family in China, including one of Fitzpatrick’s driver's license and another of him with his blue Toyota pickup, the search warrant revealed.

On July 22, photos and messages were no longer being received by Jin’s family, she wasn't answering her phone, and her social media posts stopped. Her phone showed that it was no longer in service on July 25, according to her family.

Jin’s friend filed a missing person’s report on July 26 with the sheriff’s department when she couldn’t contact her. Jin had booked a return flight in October, and her family said she did not intend to stay in the U.S.

Fitzpatrick was reported missing on July 30
, according to the man’s longtime friend and military colleague, Darryl Hoss, the San Diego Union-Tribune reported.

Hoss reported his friend missing when Fitzpatrick didn’t return from an extended camping trip to the Anza-Borrego Desert State Park, the Union-Tribune stated.

According to military records reviewed by the Union-Tribune, Fitzpatrick was honorably discharged from active service in 2010 as a chief petty officer, master parachutist, and instructor who had completed multiple tours overseas.

In 2020, Fitzpatrick pleaded guilty to misdemeanor assault and was later placed in the veteran's treatment court, hinting at underlying issues, according to the Hi-Desert Star. He eventually completed the program, and the charge was dismissed this year.

Investigators stated that on July 22, Fitzpatrick’s vehicle, a blue Toyota Tacoma truck, was captured on camera in Thermal, just south of Indio and about 60 miles north of where his body would later be found.

On Aug. 1, deputies conducted a welfare check
at Fitzpatrick’s mobile home located on 29 Palms Highway in Morongo Valley, according to the search warrant.

Detectives visited Fitzpatrick’s mobile home and found the front door open. Investigators entered to see if the couple were inside and found no one.

Detectives did find items belonging to Jin inside the home and the "odor of decomposition,” the court document stated.

Sheriff's officials also discovered and took a red suitcase that contained Jin’s property. Additionally, her straw hat, sandals, green shoes, an SD card from a Ring camera, a green helmet, and a white purse with her belongings.

Deputies also found receipts from the Marine Corps Exchange.

On July 3, Fitzpatrick was seen on a store security camera purchasing duct tape, according to the search warrant. At that time, he was seen with a white/Hispanic man, who left the store with the purchased items, the court document stated.

A month later, sheriff’s investigators served a second search warrant at the mobile home, where they took three iPhones.


MEDIA - FANG JIN: Missing from San Bernardino County, CA - July 2023 - Age 47
 
Last edited:
Update 10/18/2023:
Our sister station CBS San Diego is reporting that Fitzpatrick's family has been notified that his remains have been found in the desert.

News Channel 3 reached out to the San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department. Officials with the department said that they did not confirm anything about the discovery of John Fitzpatrick's remains.

The Department told News Channel 3 that they have not located John Fitzpatrick or Fang Jin, and their missing person cases are still open.

Public information officer Gloria Huerta said "I spoke briefly with a reporter last week and told him I could not find Fitzpatrick’s information on our Coroner’s website (exercising due diligence) and later advised him to contact the San Diego Sheriff’s Department."

This new information contradicts reporting by the San Diego Union-Tribune and CBS 8 San Diego.
 
We don't know?
News sources are saying he's been found deceased. Law enforcement is denying it.
My guess is he's been found but they can't confirm it publicly yet (maybe still notifying family). So they're going with "we never said that!"
He's still in NAMUS

 
Very confusing, I was leaning a direction until hearing he may not be dead. It would seem likely that someone told news stations he was found... Likely someone in LE or connected to LE but it is not officially confirmed?

She seemed to quit communicating before he maybe did? And she was reported missing before he was??

My guesses.... He killed her and then he suicided IF indeed he has been found. She killed him and took off BUT he was the one buying duct tape, that wanted her to come to the US, etc. AND had some treatment and some charge.

IF he is not dead then they are both still missing... No?

Third possibility is IF he is dead some other person killed them both or killed him and then took her. Etc., etc.

I am leaning towards my first one whether he is alive or dead. The little bit there is seems to hint in that direction.

I am in no way saying though there is enough reason yet to be sure.

I doubt she came to the US to murder someone or knew anyone to help her do so. What his intent was who knows... Getting someone over here alone who likely knew no one...

Just thoughts. And who knows, perhaps they are only missing and both alive and well. I seriously doubt it though.
 
Astonishing. Appears there's a Sheep Guzzler located 500 metres
from the mouth of Harper Canyon where it meets and opens out
onto Harper Flat. Also appears to be a pipe laid to two water tanks,
wonder what, if any, water might be inside them.
If these tanks are installed in like manner as the tanks at Dave
McCain Spring, then they may be painted to blend into the
landscape (Dave McCain Spring tanks are literally painted similar to
the U.S. army uniforms desert camouflage scheme).
 
Last edited:
Astonishing. Appears there's a Sheep Guzzler located 500 metres
from the mouth of Harper Canyon where it meets and opens out
onto Harper Flat. Also appears to be a pipe laid to two water tanks,
wonder what, if any, water might be inside them.
If these tanks are installed in like manner as the tanks at Dave
McCain Spring, then they may be painted to blend into the
landscape (Dave McCain Spring tanks are literally painted like the
U.S. army desert camouflage scheme).
Do you think that contributed somehow to this case?
 
Only in that, JRF (and certainly nobody over on WS) probably
had/has no knowledge of the tanks.
As far as what happened, I think I have a firmer theory now.
I figure FJ read one of the internet descriptions of Harper Flat,
got beguiled by the pictures of desert flowers and the assertions
about Indian arrowheads to be found, and decided to make Harper
Flat a destination. Something happened, perhaps she broke her leg
or got snakebit, JRF left her with whatever water they had in the shade
of some rock maybe and he moved quickly back to his vehicle. Seems
like he had to be desperate, otherwise why may he have done something
silly, I think he must have tried to drive his 2WD Tacoma up a steep hillside
to a ridge line to try to get up and to Harper Flat by his car. Seems from the
description of the vehicle, something along the lines of 'pretty wrecked', that
he may have rolled it (no rollcage) and injured himself. Maybe survived to crawl
out of the vehicle (injured) or maybe he died in the vehicle (windows broken) so
that coyotes could have accessed his remains?. FJ, in an 'English Patient'
situation, eventually dies, if not from injury or venom, then from thirst.
 
Last edited:
E
Only in that, JRF (and certainly nobody over on WS) probably
had/has no knowledge of the tanks.
As far as what happened, I think I have a firmer theory now.
I figure FJ read one of the internet descriptions of Harper Flat,
got beguiled by the pictures of desert flowers and the assertions
about Indian arrowheads to be found, and decided to make Harper
Flat a destination. Something happened, perhaps she broke her leg
or got snakebit, JRF left her with whatever water they had in the shade
of some rock maybe and he moved quickly back to his vehicle. Seems
like he had to be desperate, otherwise why may he have done something
silly, I think he must have tried to drive his 2WD Tacoma up a steep hillside
to a ridge line to try to get up and to Harper Flat by his car. Seems from the
description of the vehicle, something along the lines of 'pretty wrecked', that
he may have rolled it (no rollcage) and injured himself. Maybe survived to crawl
out of the vehicle (injured) or maybe he died in the vehicle (windows broken) so
that coyotes could have accessed his remains?. FJ, in an 'English Patient'
situation, eventually dies, if not from injury or venom, then from thirst.
I also think (at the moment) it was some kind of misadventure. But I also think about Fitzpatrick being a former navy SEAL, with lots of experience in desert settings, and I can't just see him doing silly things. Just my opinion of course.
 
"I can't just see him doing silly things". Yes, hard to understand,
unless he was certain she would die in a matter of hours, something
time desperate, like a snakebite (but why wouldn't he just carry her back?)
or a large boulder fell on and trapped her (needs a vehicle to push such?),
but every video I saw of Harper Canyon it looks about impossible
to get up those hillsides! I'm waiting for any published picture of the
vehicle, the description like 'pretty wrecked' suggests major damage,
(unless the person who made the comment is over-exaggerating)
kind of hard to figure how his vehicle could get like that. I haven't
seen a video that justs gives a continuous video all the way up to
the Canyon mouth at Harper Flat, so it's difficult to absolutely rule
out him trying something like going part way up Harper Canyon floor
and then trying to get up onto a ridgeline. A media video also said
the vehicle is still there, suggested it would need a helicopter to get
it out. Huh?
 
Last edited:
Why would the "odor of decomposition" be found in his home if she/they died out on a misadventure?

Another article from earlier this week.

The San Diego sheriff said a blue Toyota Tacoma registered to Fitzpatrick was found previously in the Harpers Flats area several miles from the human remains. The exact date that the truck was found was not released.

A spokesperson with the San Diego coroner said Monday that all records about the body, including its identity, have been sealed.

The person is still identified as “John Doe.” San Bernardino County sheriff’s spokesperson Mara Rodriguez said Monday that both Jin and Fitzpatrick are still considered missing persons.

Neither has been heard from since July 21.

We think something bad happened on the night of July 21 or the morning of the 22nd,” said David Schmidt, whose wife is from China and is a friend of Jin’s family.


The Sheriff’s Department said in one statement that Jin hired Fitzpatrick as her tour guide. Schmidt said that isn’t true, based on communication between the two that her family has recovered.

“This was a romantic relationship,” he said. “We have pages of texts demonstrating that.”


However, a search warrant filed by Detective Tyler Bengard Aug. 1 states that their disappearance was suspicious, and alerts the judge that he might find evidence of a homicide in Fitzpatrick’s home. CBS 8 obtained a copy of the search warrant and shared it online.

Bengard filed the search warrant on Aug. 1. Earlier that day, he wrote, Deputy S. Crowl had gone to Fitzpatrick’s mobile home and found the front door open. Crowl entered, found items belonging to Jin and smelled “the odor of decomposition,” Bengard stated.

Searchers seized 12 items from the house, including a red suitcase with property belonging to Jin, according to the receipt.

Two days later, they served a second warrant and took three iPhones, the CBS station found.
 
Why would the "odor of decomposition" be found in his home if she/they died out on a misadventure?

Another article from earlier this week.

The San Diego sheriff said a blue Toyota Tacoma registered to Fitzpatrick was found previously in the Harpers Flats area several miles from the human remains. The exact date that the truck was found was not released.

A spokesperson with the San Diego coroner said Monday that all records about the body, including its identity, have been sealed.

The person is still identified as “John Doe.” San Bernardino County sheriff’s spokesperson Mara Rodriguez said Monday that both Jin and Fitzpatrick are still considered missing persons.

Neither has been heard from since July 21.

We think something bad happened on the night of July 21 or the morning of the 22nd,” said David Schmidt, whose wife is from China and is a friend of Jin’s family.


The Sheriff’s Department said in one statement that Jin hired Fitzpatrick as her tour guide. Schmidt said that isn’t true, based on communication between the two that her family has recovered.

“This was a romantic relationship,” he said. “We have pages of texts demonstrating that.”


However, a search warrant filed by Detective Tyler Bengard Aug. 1 states that their disappearance was suspicious, and alerts the judge that he might find evidence of a homicide in Fitzpatrick’s home. CBS 8 obtained a copy of the search warrant and shared it online.

Bengard filed the search warrant on Aug. 1. Earlier that day, he wrote, Deputy S. Crowl had gone to Fitzpatrick’s mobile home and found the front door open. Crowl entered, found items belonging to Jin and smelled “the odor of decomposition,” Bengard stated.

Searchers seized 12 items from the house, including a red suitcase with property belonging to Jin, according to the receipt.

Two days later, they served a second warrant and took three iPhones, the CBS station found.
Thanks for reminding me of this🙈. I had forgotten about it. I hope the car and the bodies will give an idea about what happened.
 
"I can't just see him doing silly things". Yes, hard to understand,
unless he was certain she would die in a matter of hours, something
time desperate, like a snakebite (but why wouldn't he just carry her back?)
or a large boulder fell on and trapped her (needs a vehicle to push such?),
but every video I saw of Harper Canyon it looks about impossible
to get up those hillsides! I'm waiting for any published picture of the
vehicle, the description like 'pretty wrecked' suggests major damage,
(unless the person who made the comment is over-exaggerating)
kind of hard to figure how his vehicle could get like that. I haven't
seen a video that justs gives a continuous video all the way up to
the Canyon mouth at Harper Flat, so it's difficult to absolutely rule
out him trying something like going part way up Harper Canyon floor
and then trying to get up onto a ridgeline. A media video also said
the vehicle is still there, suggested it would need a helicopter to get
it out. Huh?
I am only now just catching up on the entire thread but so what about smell of decomp in his home? And "supposedly went camping" stands out. Is there a single thing factual after them buying supplies that says she ever left the mobile home? I am still reading so maybe there is although I am doubting it. Even if there is this one has a strong one way lean imo. But maybe I'm all wet since still reading...
 
Why would the "odor of decomposition" be found in his home if she/they died out on a misadventure?

Another article from earlier this week.

The San Diego sheriff said a blue Toyota Tacoma registered to Fitzpatrick was found previously in the Harpers Flats area several miles from the human remains. The exact date that the truck was found was not released.

A spokesperson with the San Diego coroner said Monday that all records about the body, including its identity, have been sealed.

The person is still identified as “John Doe.” San Bernardino County sheriff’s spokesperson Mara Rodriguez said Monday that both Jin and Fitzpatrick are still considered missing persons.

Neither has been heard from since July 21.

We think something bad happened on the night of July 21 or the morning of the 22nd,” said David Schmidt, whose wife is from China and is a friend of Jin’s family.


The Sheriff’s Department said in one statement that Jin hired Fitzpatrick as her tour guide. Schmidt said that isn’t true, based on communication between the two that her family has recovered.

“This was a romantic relationship,” he said. “We have pages of texts demonstrating that.”


However, a search warrant filed by Detective Tyler Bengard Aug. 1 states that their disappearance was suspicious, and alerts the judge that he might find evidence of a homicide in Fitzpatrick’s home. CBS 8 obtained a copy of the search warrant and shared it online.

Bengard filed the search warrant on Aug. 1. Earlier that day, he wrote, Deputy S. Crowl had gone to Fitzpatrick’s mobile home and found the front door open. Crowl entered, found items belonging to Jin and smelled “the odor of decomposition,” Bengard stated.

Searchers seized 12 items from the house, including a red suitcase with property belonging to Jin, according to the receipt.

Two days later, they served a second warrant and took three iPhones, the CBS station found.
I should have read further. This makes MUCH more sense.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,014
Messages
242,036
Members
974
Latest member
elimortonslywir
Back
Top Bottom