AR CASSIE COMPTON: Missing from Stuttgart, Arkansas - 14 Sept 2014 - Age 15

1606966617687.png 1583355527368.png

Cassie was last seen in Stuttgart, Arkansas sometime after 6:00 p.m. of September 14, 2014, after spending the day at a demolition derby with friends.

A short time after she arrived home, she left again, telling her mother she was going to the store to pick up some things. She had a black LG smart phone with no charger. She never returned home and has never been heard from again.

It's uncharacteristic of Cassie to leave without warning; her mother said they always kept in touch. She lived with her mother and her mother's fiance at the time of her disappearance; her father lived in Oklahoma. She was home-schooled and working to obtain a GED certificate. Little evidence is available as to her fate.

NamUs The National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs)

Last edited by a moderator:
Her mother's fiance has been the main POI. Here's an interesting article about the case as of last year:

"He says Judy was sick, he said that he was in the back bedroom with her and he never saw Cassie. He said she came in, grabbed something, she was there for less than five minutes. He walked outside and a couple of minutes later she was gone," Lafferty explained.

Back in September Kimsey, Cassie's mother told a different story than Rhodes told while in jail, about what he was doing that night.

"He was in the house, and he was cooking dinner, that's what he was getting ready to do whenever she came home, was cook supper because I was really sick," Kimsey said.


Monday Night Mystery: Cassie Compton​

This month, FOX16 News is diving into a Monday Night Mystery.

This Monday, we discuss the mystery surrounding Cassie Compton.

She’s been missing since 2014.

The then 15-year-old was last seen outside her Stuttgart home.

The case has picked up national attention with podcasts and TV shows as theories circulate and rumor the community.

Stuttgart Police officials confirm the case is still open and tips continue to come in.

Our Mitch McCoy talks with seasoned police investigators and prosecutors live on and on FOX16’s Facebook at 7 p.m. Monday.

Viewers can interact with McCoy and the Monday Night Mystery contributors on Facebook Live using #MondayNightMystery. The contributors will answer questions in real-time and provide expert analysis during the show.

Using the power of their experience cracking cases, they will shed light on what’s likely happening inside the police investigation.

Authorities looking at TikTok video that might show missing Arkansas girl Cassie Compton​



After eight years, Stuttgart teen Cassie Compton’s disappearance remains a mystery​

It has been eight years since Cassie Compton disappeared without a trace.

Detective Shawn Watson now investigates Cassie’s disappearance for the Stuttgart Police Department. He said the department still follows up on leads involving the case.

“New leads do not necessarily mean new suspects. All leads are followed up on, though not all of them have helped our case,” Watson said.

Forum statistics

Latest member