Amy Gellert was fatally stabbed by a masked man in the driveway of her family's home in Cocoa Beach, Florida, more than 25 years ago

On March 20, 1994, Robert and Bunny Lehton got home after spending the evening in church in Cocoa Beach, Florida. When they entered home they encountered a masked man who was carrying a knife and a gun. The masked man tied the couple and walked around the house, as if waiting for someone.